Mounting evidence that managed and introduced bees have negative impacts on wild bees: an updated review

• Published in: Current research in insect science Vol. 2; p. 100043
• Main Authors: Iwasaki, Jay M., Hogendoorn, Katja
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Netherlands Elsevier B.V 01.01.2022; Elsevier
• Subjects: Apis; Bees; Bombus; Competition; honey; Managed; pathogenicity; Pathogens; pollination; Pollinators; reproductive performance; Review; systematic review; Competition; Pathogens; Apis; Pollinators; Managed; Bees; Bombus
• ISSN: 2666-5158; 2666-5158
• DOI: 10.1016/j.cris.2022.100043

•Worldwide there is increasing reliance and concern for pollinators, primarily bees•Wild bees may be threatened by habitat loss, pathogens, and perhaps managed bees•The literature supports significant evidence for competition from managed bees•However, the factors affecting bee competition need be examined in context•Conserving pollinators requires action that focuses less on managed species Worldwide, the use of managed bees for crop pollination and honey production has increased dramatically. Concerns about the pressures of these increases on native ecosystems has resulted in a recent expansion in the literature on this subject. To collate and update current knowledge, we performed a systematic review of the literature on the effects of managed and introduced bees on native ecosystems, focusing on the effects on wild bees. To enable comparison over time, we used the same search terms and focused on the same impacts as earlier reviews. This review covers: (a) interference and resource competition between introduced or managed bees and native bees; (b) effects of introduced or managed bees on pollination of native plants and weeds; and (c) transmission and infectivity of pathogens; and classifies effects into positive, negative, or neutral. Compared to a 2017 review, we found that the number of papers on this issue has increased by 47%. The highest increase was seen in papers on pathogen spill-over, but in the last five years considerable additional information about competition between managed and wild bees has also become available. Records of negative effects have increased from 53% of papers reporting negative effects in 2017 to 66% at present. The majority of these studies investigated effects on visitation and foraging behaviour. While only a few studies experimentally assessed impacts on wild bee reproductive output, 78% of these demonstrated negative effects. Plant composition and pollination was negatively affected in 7% of studies, and 79% of studies on pathogens reported potential negative effects of managed or introduced bees on wild bees. Taken together, the evidence increasingly suggests that managed and introduced bees negatively affect wild bees, and this knowledge should inform actions to prevent further harm to native ecosystems.