The Other as Brother: Nation-Building and Ethnic Ambivalence in Early Jewish-Israeli Anthropology

• Published in: Anthropological quarterly Vol. 82; no. 2; pp. 477 - 508
• Main Authors: Goodman, Yehuda, Loss, Joseph
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Washington, DC George Washington University Institute for Ethnographic Research 01.04.2009; Washington University Institute for Ethnology Research; Institute for Ethnographic Research
• Subjects: Agricultural production; Ambivalence; Anthropological research; Anthropologists; Anthropology; Ashkenazi Jews; Brothers; Case studies; Cultural anthropology; Cultural relations; Discourse strategies; Ethnicity; Ethnography; Ethnology; Field of ethnology; Hebrews; Immigration; Israel; Jewish diaspora; Jewish people; Jews; Linguistic anthropology; Nation building; Political anthropology; Political aspects; Political development; Research subjects; Siblings; Social aspects; Sociology of Knowledge; Sources and methods; State Formation; Violence; Near East; Israel; New York; Morocco; Tel Aviv Israel; United States > US; Africa; Nation; Sociology of knowledge; Ambivalence; Construction; Ethnicity; Anthropology; Orientalism; Jew; Subject
• ISSN: 0003-5491; 1534-1518; 1534-1518
• DOI: 10.1353/anq.0.0062

Most depictions of "peripheral," nation-states' anthropologies assume that the anthropology's Other is a given, pre-defined subordinated group. Using the beginnings of Israeli anthropology (1960s-1970s) as our case study, we explore instead how while appropriating academic dominant paradigms of the time and aspiring to national unity, Israeli anthropologists were articulating through their choices of research subjects and research topics, and through their interpretations of the field an ethnic difference between themselves, European Jews and their "brothers," Oriental Jews. We follow the ambivalent discursive strategies through which this research project was created, and explore its implications for understanding other nation-building anthropologies.