Heritage-based tribalism in Big Data ecologies: Deploying origin myths for antagonistic othering

• Published in: Big data & society Vol. 8; no. 1
• Main Authors: Bonacchi, Chiara, Krzyzanska, Marta
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: London, England SAGE Publications 01.01.2021; Sage Publications Ltd; SAGE Publishing
• Subjects: Activism; Big Data; Ethnic relations; News media; Otherness; Qualitative analysis; Qualitative research; Racism; Social media; Websites; Twitter; tribalism; origin myths; othering; Big Data ecologies; Heritage
• ISSN: 2053-9517; 2053-9517
• DOI: 10.1177/20539517211003310

This article presents a conceptual and methodological framework to study heritage-based tribalism in Big Data ecologies by combining approaches from the humanities, social and computing sciences. We use such a framework to examine how ideas of human origin and ancestry are deployed on Twitter for purposes of antagonistic ‘othering’. Our goal is to equip researchers with theory and analytical tools for investigating divisive online uses of the past in today’s networked societies. In particular, we apply notions of heritage, othering and neo-tribalism, and both data-intensive and qualitative methods to the case of people’s engagements with the news of Cheddar Man’s DNA on Twitter. We show that heritage-based tribalism in Big Data ecologies is uniquely shaped as an assemblage by the coalescing of different forms of antagonistic othering. Those that co-occur most frequently are the ones that draw on ‘Views on Race’, ‘Trust in Experts’ and ‘Political Leaning’. The framings of the news that were most influential in triggering heritage-based tribalism were introduced by both right- and left-leaning newspaper outlets and by activist websites. We conclude that heritage-themed communications that rely on provocative narratives on social media tend to be labelled as political and not to be conducive to positive change in people’s attitudes towards issues such as racism.