Single Versus Multiple Events Error Potential Detection in a BCI-Controlled Car Game With Continuous and Discrete Feedback

• Published in: IEEE transactions on biomedical engineering Vol. 63; no. 3; pp. 519 - 529
• Main Authors: Kreilinger, Alex, Hiebel, Hannah, Muller-Putz, Gernot R.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States IEEE 01.03.2016; The Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc. (IEEE)
• Subjects: Accuracy; Adult; Analytical models; brain-computer interface (BCI); Brain-Computer Interfaces - standards; continuous feedback; Electrodes; electroencephalogram (EEG); Electroencephalography; Electroencephalography - standards; error potential (ErrP); Feedback; Female; Games; Humans; Imagination; Male; Mathematical model; Signal Processing, Computer-Assisted; Training; Video Games; Young Adult; continuous feedback; error potential (ErrP); electroencephalogram (EEG); Brain–computer interface (BCI)
• ISSN: 0018-9294; 1558-2531; 1558-2531
• DOI: 10.1109/TBME.2015.2465866

Objective: This work aimed to find and evaluate a new method for detecting errors in continuous brain-computer interface (BCI) applications. Instead of classifying errors on a single-trial basis, the new method was based on multiple events (MEs) analysis to increase the accuracy of error detection. Methods: In a BCI-driven car game, based on motor imagery (MI), discrete events were triggered whenever subjects collided with coins and/or barriers. Coins counted as correct events, whereas barriers were errors. This new method, termed ME method, combined and averaged the classification results of single events (SEs) and determined the correctness of MI trials, which consisted of event sequences instead of SEs. The benefit of this method was evaluated in an offline simulation. In an online experiment, the new method was used to detect erroneous MI trials. Such MI trials were discarded and could be repeated by the users. Results: We found that, even with low SE error potential (ErrP) detection rates, feasible accuracies can be achieved when combining MEs to distinguish erroneous from correct MI trials. Online, all subjects reached higher scores with error detection than without, at the cost of longer times needed for completing the game. Conclusion: Findings suggest that ErrP detection may become a reliable tool for monitoring continuous states in BCI applications when combining MEs. Significance: This paper demonstrates a novel technique for detecting errors in online continuous BCI applications, which yields promising results even with low single-trial detection rates.