Form function of sulcus acusticus of the sagittal otolith in seven Sciaenidae ( Acanthuriformes ) species using geometric morphometrics ( southwestern Atlantic )

• Published in: Journal of fish biology Vol. 103; no. 5; pp. 1199 - 1213
• Main Authors: Verocai, José E., Cabrera, Fernanda, Lombarte, Antoni, Norbis, Walter
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Oxford Wiley Subscription Services, Inc 01.11.2023
• Subjects: Acanthuriformes; Biological noise; Biological Sciences; Clustering; convergent evolution; Deformation; Environmental factors; Fish; geometry; Hearing; Morphometry; Multivariate analysis; Otoliths; Phylogenetics; Phylogeny; principal component analysis; Principal components analysis; Sciaenidae; selection pressure; Shape; Sibling species; Sound production; Temporal distribution; Variance analysis
• ISSN: 0022-1112; 1095-8649; 1095-8649
• DOI: 10.1111/jfb.15521

The morphology of otoliths determines the function they perform, and it is influenced by genetic and environmental factors. Knowing those relationships is necessary to understand the role of hearing in fish. The objectives of this work were: exploring the shape of the sulcus of the sagittal otolith in seven species of Sciaenidae, in relation to sound production, and analyzing whether the shape and size of the sulcus can be used as a phylogenetic character. For this purpose, geometric morphometry analysis was carried out using landmarks data. It was found that there is an influence of size on the shape of the sulcus , and significant differences were found between the shapes of the sulcus (permutational multivariate analysis of variance). Three general shapes of the sulcus were identified (using principal component analysis, canonical variate analysis, and clustering): (1) in species that produce sounds at dominant frequencies <350 Hz, the deformation of the sulcus showed a tendency towards circularity of the ostium ; (2) in those species that produce sounds at frequencies >350 Hz, the ostium showed a flattened ovoid shape, and the cauda increased its length; (3) the species that do not produce sounds, did not show any modifications, relative to the form of consensus. Despite finding sister species that presented similar sulcus shapes in the phylogeny, the results did not confirm that this can be used as a phylogenetic character. This work discusses whether the combined effects of phylogenetic legacy and natural functional selection have led to convergent evolution for the sulcus form. The differences presented by the sulcus of species that occupy the same clade, could indicate that there is a displacement of characters. The sagittal otolith and the sensory macula associated with the sulcus acusticus are highly plastic structures that are subject to strong evolutionary pressure in relation to environmental and behavioral factors, resulting in great variability in shapes that can be associated with a specific character. The variation in the shape of the sulcus would allow the analysed species to coexist in the same coastal soundscapes, without losing their particular hearing needs, even in case of overlapping their spatial and temporal distribution areas.