Predicting highway lane-changing maneuvers: A benchmark analysis of machine and ensemble learning algorithms

• Published in: Physica A Vol. 612; p. 128471
• Main Authors: Khelfa, Basma, Ba, Ibrahima, Tordeux, Antoine
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Elsevier B.V 15.02.2023
• Subjects: Benchmark analysis; Data-based algorithm; Ensemble learning techniques; Highway traffic; Lane change prediction; Rule-based model; Highway traffic; Data-based algorithm; Rule-based model; Benchmark analysis; Ensemble learning techniques; Lane change prediction
• ISSN: 0378-4371
• DOI: 10.1016/j.physa.2023.128471

Understanding and predicting highway lane-change maneuvers is essential for driving modeling and its automation. The development of data-based lane-changing decision-making algorithms is nowadays in full expansion. We compare empirically in this article different machine and ensemble learning classification techniques to the MOBIL rule-based model using trajectory data of European two-lane highways. The analysis relies on instantaneous measurements of up to twenty-four spatial–temporal variables with the four neighboring vehicles on current and adjacent lanes. Preliminary descriptive investigations by principal component and logistic analyses allow identifying main variables intending a driver to change lanes. We predict two types of discretionary lane-change maneuvers: overtaking (from the slow to the fast lane) and fold-down (from the fast to the slow lane). The prediction accuracy is quantified using total, lane-changing and lane-keeping errors and associated receiver operating characteristic curves. The benchmark analysis includes logistic model, linear discriminant, decision tree, naïve Bayes classifier, support vector machine, neural network machine learning algorithms, and up to ten bagging and stacking ensemble learning meta-heuristics. If the rule-based model provides limited predicting accuracy, the data-based algorithms, devoid of modeling bias, allow significant prediction improvements. Cross validations show that selected neural networks and stacking algorithms allow predicting from a single observation both fold-down and overtaking maneuvers up to four seconds in advance with high accuracy.