Cultural historical research in support of inclusive classrooms two approaches in dialogue

• Published in: Outlines. Critical practice studies Vol. 26; pp. 37 - 56
• Main Authors: Stepaniuk, Inna, Ferholt, Beth
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: The Outlines Association 12.09.2024
• Subjects: cultural historical research; romantic science; playword; schools; cultural-historical activity theory; inclusive classrooms
• ISSN: 1399-5510; 1904-0210
• DOI: 10.7146/ocps.v26i.148597

This article showcases the potential of dialogue within cultural historical research (CHR) to enhance our understanding of and advocacy for inclusivity in schools. It illustrates how the authors, each rooted in distinct subfields – cultural historical activity theory (CHAT) and romantic science – employ a unique approach to knowledge production regarding inclusive classrooms. By refraining from the pursuit of agreement and instead fostering an environment where their studies are juxtaposed, the authors engage in what they term “inclusive coauthoring,” approaching each other’s methodologies with an asset-based, solidarity-seeking stance. The first author utilizes excerpts from an ethnographic study in an elementary classroom to demonstrate how CHAT can elucidate the intricate dynamics of diverse classrooms, shedding light on mechanisms of inclusion/exclusion and identifying potential barriers (opportunities) to inclusive practices. On the other hand, the second author illustrates how a romantic science perspective can empower educators to cultivate inclusivity in ways previously unexplored before their deep engagement with the study. Uniting in collaboration around shared goals rather than shared methods, led the authors to unforeseen advancements, particularly in one of the studies.