Post Training Uncertainty Calibration Of Deep Networks For Medical Image Segmentation

• Published in: Proceedings (International Symposium on Biomedical Imaging) pp. 1052 - 1056
• Main Authors: Rousseau, Axel-Jan, Becker, Thijs, Bertels, Jeroen, Blaschko, Matthew B., Valkenborg, Dirk
• Format: Conference Proceeding
• Language: English
• Published: IEEE 13.04.2021
• Subjects: Calibration; confidence calibration; deep learning; Image segmentation; Measurement; Medical image segmentation; Monte Carlo methods; Neural networks; Training; Uncertainty; uncertainty estimation
• ISSN: 1945-8452
• DOI: 10.1109/ISBI48211.2021.9434131

Neural networks for automated image segmentation are typically trained to achieve maximum accuracy, while less attention has been given to the calibration of their confidence scores. However, well-calibrated confidence scores provide valuable information towards the user. We investigate several post hoc calibration methods that are straightforward to implement, some of which are novel. They are compared to Monte Carlo (MC) dropout and are applied to neural networks trained with cross-entropy (CE) and soft Dice (SD) losses on BraTS 2018 and ISLES 2018. Surprisingly, models trained on SD loss are not necessarily less calibrated than those trained on CE loss. In all cases, at least one post hoc method improves the calibration. There is limited consistency across the results, so we can't conclude on one method being superior. In all cases, post hoc calibration is competitive with MC dropout. Although average calibration improves compared to the base model, subject-level variance of the calibration remains similar.