Efficient context-dependent model building based on clustering posterior distributions for non-coding sequences

• Published in: BMC evolutionary biology Vol. 9; no. 1; p. 87
• Main Authors: Baele, Guy, Van de Peer, Yves, Vansteelandt, Stijn
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: London BioMed Central 30.04.2009; BioMed Central Ltd; BMC
• Subjects: Animal Systematics/Taxonomy/Biogeography; Animals; Bayes factors; Bayes Theorem; Biomedical and Life Sciences; Cluster Analysis; Computational Biology - methods; Entomology; Evolution; Evolution, Molecular; Evolutionary Biology; Genetic algorithms; Genetics and Population Dynamics; Life Sciences; Likelihood Functions; Models, Genetic; Molecular evolution; Research Article; RNA, Ribosomal - genetics; Statistical models; Thermodynamics; Posterior Variance; Substitution Behavior; Thermodynamic Integration; Marginal Likelihood; Rate Class
• ISSN: 1471-2148; 1471-2148
• DOI: 10.1186/1471-2148-9-87

Background Many recent studies that relax the assumption of independent evolution of sites have done so at the expense of a drastic increase in the number of substitution parameters. While additional parameters cannot be avoided to model context-dependent evolution, a large increase in model dimensionality is only justified when accompanied with careful model-building strategies that guard against overfitting. An increased dimensionality leads to increases in numerical computations of the models, increased convergence times in Bayesian Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithms and even more tedious Bayes Factor calculations. Results We have developed two model-search algorithms which reduce the number of Bayes Factor calculations by clustering posterior densities to decide on the equality of substitution behavior in different contexts. The selected model's fit is evaluated using a Bayes Factor, which we calculate via model-switch thermodynamic integration. To reduce computation time and to increase the precision of this integration, we propose to split the calculations over different computers and to appropriately calibrate the individual runs. Using the proposed strategies, we find, in a dataset of primate Ancestral Repeats, that careful modeling of context-dependent evolution may increase model fit considerably and that the combination of a context-dependent model with the assumption of varying rates across sites offers even larger improvements in terms of model fit. Using a smaller nuclear SSU rRNA dataset, we show that context-dependence may only become detectable upon applying model-building strategies. Conclusion While context-dependent evolutionary models can increase the model fit over traditional independent evolutionary models, such complex models will often contain too many parameters. Justification for the added parameters is thus required so that only those parameters that model evolutionary processes previously unaccounted for are added to the evolutionary model. To obtain an optimal balance between the number of parameters in a context-dependent model and the performance in terms of model fit, we have designed two parameter-reduction strategies and we have shown that model fit can be greatly improved by reducing the number of parameters in a context-dependent evolutionary model.