The origin of the pelagobenthic metazoan life cycle: what's sex got to do with it?

• Published in: Integrative and comparative biology Vol. 46; no. 6; pp. 683 - 690
• Main Authors: Degnan, Sandie M., Degnan, Bernard M.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: England Oxford University Press 01.12.2006; Oxford Publishing Limited (England)
• Subjects: Animals; Bilateria; Biology; Embryonic growth stage; Embryos; Epithelial cells; Evolution; Hypotheses; Larvae; Larval development; Life cycle; Life cycles; Metamorphosis; Metamorphosis: A Multikingdom Approach; Metazoa; Phylogeny; Recapitulation theory; Sponges; Water column
• ISSN: 1540-7063; 1557-7023; 1557-7023
• DOI: 10.1093/icb/icl028

The biphasic (pelagobenthic) life cycle is found throughout the animal kingdom, and includes gametogenesis, embryogenesis, and metamorphosis. From a tangled web of hypotheses on the origin and evolution of the metazoan pelagobenthic life cycle, current opinion appears to favor a simple, larval-like holopelagic ancestor that independently settled multiple times to incorporate a benthic phase into the life cycle. This hypothesis derives originally from Haeckel's (1874) Gastraea theory of ontogeny recapitulating phylogeny, in which the gastrula is viewed as the recapitulation of a gastraean ancestor that evolved via selection on a simple, planktonic hollow ball of cells to develop the capacity to feed. Here, we propose an equally plausible hypothesis that the origin of the metazoan pelagobenthic life cycle was a direct consequence of sexual reproduction in a likely holobenthic ancestor. In doing so, we take into account new insights from poriferan development and from molecular phylogenies. In this scenario, the gastrula does not represent a recapitulation, but simply an embryological stage that is an outcome of sexual reproduction. The embryo can itself be considered as the precursor to a biphasic lifestyle, with the embryo representing one phase and the adult another phase. This hypothesis is more parsimonious because it precludes the need for multiple, independent origins of the benthic form. It is then reasonable to consider that multilayered, ciliated embryos ultimately released into the water column are subject to natural selection for dispersal/longevity/feeding that sets them on the evolutionary trajectory towards the crown metazoan planktonic larvae. These new insights from poriferan development thus clearly support the intercalation hypothesis of bilaterian larval evolution, which we now believe should be extended to discussions of the origin of biphasy in the metazoan last common ancestor.