Stability of diurnal cortisol measures across days, weeks, and years across middle childhood and early adolescence: Exploring the role of age, pubertal development, and sex

• Published in: Psychoneuroendocrinology Vol. 100; pp. 67 - 74
• Main Authors: Kuhlman, Kate Ryan, Robles, Theodore F., Dickenson, Leah, Reynolds, Bridget, Repetti, Rena L.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: England Elsevier Ltd 01.02.2019
• Subjects: Adolescent; Adolescent Development - physiology; Age Factors; Child; Child Development - physiology; Circadian Rhythm - physiology; Development; Female; HPA axis; Humans; Hydrocortisone - metabolism; Hypothalamo-Hypophyseal System - physiology; Longitudinal Studies; Male; Pituitary-Adrenal System - physiology; Puberty - physiology; Saliva - metabolism; Sex Characteristics; Stability; Study design; Time Factors; Study design; Development; HPA axis; Stability; Adolescent
• ISSN: 0306-4530; 1873-3360; 1873-3360
• DOI: 10.1016/j.psyneuen.2018.09.033

•Diurnal cortisol indices had stability estimates between .46 and .77 over 8 days.•Diurnal cortisol indices had stability estimates between .46 and .76 over 3 weeks.•Diurnal cortisol indices had stability estimates between .65 and .78 over 3 years.•Male youth had more stable morning cortisol across weeks and years than females.•The only stability indices that varied by age, sex, or puberty were waking and CAR. Effective regulation of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis (HPA-axis) has been linked to numerous health outcomes. Within-person variation in diurnal measures of HPA-axis regulation assessed over days, months, and years can range between 50–73% of total variation. In this study of 59 youth (ages 8–13), we quantified the stability of the cortisol awakening response (CAR), the diurnal slope, and tonic cortisol concentrations at waking and bedtime across 8 days (2 sets of 4 consecutive days separated by 3 weeks), 3 weeks, and 3 years. We then compared the stability of these indices across three key developmental factors: age, pubertal status, and sex. Youth provided 4 saliva samples per day (waking, 30 min post-waking, before dinner, and before bedtime) for 4 consecutive days during the 3rd week of an ongoing 8-week daily diary study. Youth repeated this same sampling procedure 3 weeks and 3 years later. Using multi-level modeling, we computed the amount of variance in diurnal HPA-axis regulation that was accounted for by nesting an individual’s diurnal cortisol indices within days, weeks, or years. Across days, diurnal slope was the most stable index, whereas waking cortisol and CAR were the least stable. All indices except bedtime cortisol were similarly stable when measured across weeks, and all indices were uniformly stable when measured across 3 years. Boys, younger participants, and youth earlier in their pubertal development at study enrollment exhibited greater HPA-axis stability overall compared with females and older, more physically mature participants. We conclude that important within- and between-subjects questions can be answered about health and human development by studying HPA-axis regulation, and selection of the index of interest should be determined in part by its psychometric characteristics. To this end, we propose a decision tree to guide study design for research in pediatric samples by longitudinal timeframe and sample characteristics.