Massive LMS log data analysis for the early prediction of course-agnostic student performance

• Published in: Computers and education Vol. 163; p. 104108
• Main Authors: Riestra-González, Moises, Paule-Ruíz, Maria del Puerto, Ortin, Francisco
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Elsevier Ltd 01.04.2021
• Subjects: Early prediction; Interaction patterns; Learning management systems; Machine learning; Student performance; Learning management systems; Student performance; Machine learning; Early prediction; Interaction patterns
• ISSN: 0360-1315; 1873-782X
• DOI: 10.1016/j.compedu.2020.104108

The early prediction of students' performance is a valuable resource to improve their learning. If we are able to detect at-risk students in the initial stages of the course, we will have more time to improve their performance. Likewise, excellent students could be motivated with customized additional activities. This is why there are research works aimed to early detect students’ performance. Some of them try to achieve it with the analysis of LMS log files, which store information about student interaction with the LMS. Many works create predictive models with the log files generated for the whole course, but those models are not useful for early prediction because the actual log information used for predicting is different to the one used to train the models. Other works do create predictive models with the log information retrieved at the early stages of courses, but they are just focused on a particular type of course. In this work, we use machine learning to create models for the early prediction of students' performance in solving LMS assignments, by just analyzing the LMS log files generated up to the moment of prediction. Moreover, our models are course agnostic, because the datasets are created with all the University of Oviedo1 courses for one academic year. We predict students' performance at 10%, 25%, 33% and 50% of the course length. Our objective is not to predict the exact student's mark in LMS assignments, but to detect at-risk, fail and excellent students in the early stages of the course. That is why we create different classification models for each of those three student groups. Decision tree, nave Bayes, logistic regression, multilayer perceptron (MLP) neural network, and support vector machine models are created and evaluated. Accuracies of all the models grow as the moment of prediction increases. Although all the algorithms but nave Bayes show accuracy differences lower than 5%, MLP obtains the best performance: from 80.1% accuracy when 10% of the course has been delivered to 90.1% when half of it has taken place. We also discuss the LMS log entries that most influence the students' performance. By using a clustering algorithm, we detect six different clusters of students regarding their interaction with the LMS. Analyzing the interaction patterns of each cluster, we find that those patterns are repeated in all the early stages of the course. Finally, we show how four out of those six student-LMS interaction patterns have a strong correlation with students' performance. •Early prediction of students' performance is achieved by analyzing LMS logs.•Our models detect at-risk and excellent students at early stages of the courses.•We find six student-LMS interaction patterns repeated in all stages of the course.•Four student clusters are correlated with the students' performance.•Our predictive and clustering models do not depend on particular course features.