How poetry and song can grapple with the dialectics of crisis and agency, and become tools for transformative research

• Published in: Outlines. Critical practice studies Vol. 25; pp. 1 - 26
• Main Author: Hopwood, Nick
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Copenhagen, Denmark The Outlines Association 19.07.2024; Outlines, Critical Practice Studies
• Subjects: Activists; Adaptation; Collaboration; Collective action; Dialectics; Imagination; Inequality; Neoliberalism; Oppression; Traditions; cultural-historical theory; agency; crisis; arts; transformative research
• ISSN: 1399-5510; 1904-0210
• DOI: 10.7146/ocps.v25i.141286

 Activist scholarship inspired by a cultural-historical tradition often seeks to foster agency with people facing crisis. The aim is to develop new understandings and bases for action that can help people break away from the status quo and change what is possible. Cultural-historical theory understands crisis and agency dialectically, linking both to individual and social transformation. Dialectic understandings of crisis foreground breakdown and renewal. Dialectic understandings of agency foreground personal contributions with social consequence and contingency. I argue that these understandings are crucial as a point of departure in research where we stand alongside others on grappling with matters of equity and justice. However, establishing these as a shared basis for resisting, reimaging and rebelliously acting is not straightforward and requires countering dominant neoliberal framings. Arts-based forms have significant potential to enable precisely such disruptive thinking. The line ‘Dance on the shark’s wing’, opens a poem by Nikos Kavadias, bluring the lines between the real and the imagined, the fearful and the possible. ‘No One Is Alone’, a song from Sondheim’s ‘Into the Woods’, tells a story of how individual interest is overcome through collective wisdom and consequential action. These examples are discussed as potential transformative tools that could provoke and support collective radical imagination based on coherent understandings of individual agentic contributions to collective struggles. An argument is presented to embrace arts genres as means to destabilise engrained ways of thinking about crisis and agency, thus strengthening collaborative efforts in activist research