Forward modeling to investigate inversion artifacts resulting from time-lapse electrical resistivity tomography during rainfall simulations

• Published in: Journal of applied geophysics Vol. 145; pp. 39 - 49
• Main Authors: Carey, Austin M., Paige, Ginger B., Carr, Bradley J., Dogan, Mine
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Elsevier B.V 01.10.2017
• Subjects: Electrical resistivity tomography; Infiltration; Rainfall simulation; Vadose zone; Rainfall simulation; Artifacts; Electrical resistivity tomography; Infiltration; Vadose zone
• ISSN: 0926-9851; 1879-1859
• DOI: 10.1016/j.jappgeo.2017.08.002

Time-lapse electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) is commonly used as a minimally invasive tool to study infiltration processes. In 2014, we conducted field studies coupling variable intensity rainfall simulation with high-resolution ERT to study the real-time partitioning of rainfall into surface and subsurface response. The significant contrast in resistivity in the subsurface from large changes in subsurface moisture resulted in artifacts during the inversion process of the time-lapse ERT data collected using a dipole-dipole electrode array. These artifacts, which are not representative of real subsurface moisture dynamics, have been shown to arise during time-lapse inversion of ERT data and may be subject to misinterpretation. Forward modeling of the infiltration process post field experiments using a two-layer system (saprolite overlain by a soil layer) was used to generate synthetic datasets. The synthetic data were used to investigate the influence of both changes in volumetric moisture content and electrode configuration on the development of the artifacts identified in the field datasets. For the dipole-dipole array, we found that a decrease in the resistivity of the bottom layer by 67% resulted in a 50% reduction in artifact development. Artifacts for the seven additional array configurations tested, ranged from a 19% increase in artifact development (using an extended dipole-dipole array) to as much as a 96% decrease in artifact development (using a wenner-alpha array), compared to that of the dipole-dipole array. Moreover, these arrays varied in their ability to accurately delineate the infiltration front. Model results showed that the modified pole-dipole array was able to accurately image the infiltration zone and presented fewer artifacts for our experiments. In this study, we identify an optimal array type for imaging rainfall-infiltration dynamics that reduces artifacts. The influence of moisture contrast between the infiltrating water and the bulk subsurface material was characterized and shown to be a major factor in contributing to artifact development. Through forward modeling, this study highlights the importance of considering array type and subsurface moisture conditions when using time-lapse resistivity to obtain reliable estimates of vadose zone flow processes during rainfall-infiltration events. •Artifacts develop from time-lapse inversion of rainfall simulation resistivity data.•Artifacts are classified as regions not representative of true vadose zone dynamics.•Forward modeling can be used to investigate the development of these artifacts.•Electrode configuration and moisture condition affect inversion results.•An optimal electrode configuration is identified based on forward modeling results.